KMW Consulting markKMW/Consulting
Bid Leak Audit
30:00
Shared screen
Step 1 · 2 minutes

Frame the call

Where jobs leak between the estimate and the signature

Set the agenda, earn the right to ask about money, and tell him you'll say so if it's not a fit. Share the prospect window now.

30 minutes. Your numbers, not opinions. If this isn't a fit, you'll hear it from me.

My painting sales stats
$4,589,431sold as an estimator
595residential jobs
$7,713average job
$1,880,760my highest sales year
Today
01

Your numbers

Estimates, average job, close rate, open bids.

02

Where it leaks

Before the estimate, after the price, in the follow-up.

03

What it costs you

Every month and every year, in your own numbers.

04

The fix

What I'd install, what it costs, and how many jobs cover it.

Say"Thanks for taking the time, [owner]. Quick background: I was a residential painting estimator in Denver for three years. I walked the homes, wrote the bids and chased the signatures. I sold $4,589,431 across 595 jobs, and $1,880,760 in my best year. Today I want to find where jobs leak between the estimate and the signature at [company]. I'll ask a lot about numbers. If we're not a fit, I'll tell you."
Then ask"Before we start, what made you take this call? What would make the next 30 minutes worth it?"
Why he took the call (his words)
Step 2 · 8 minutes

Your numbers

Get numbers, not opinions. A rough guess beats "I don't know". Keep the totals to yourself until step 4.

Rough is fine. We'll add it all up at the end.

Revenue, last 12 months
$
Sizes the opportunity and checks fit.
My highest sales year: $1,880,760 as one estimator
Share of the work that's residential repaint
%
The system is built for in-home residential bids.
Average job
$
Every dollar figure later runs off this.
$7,713 avg over 595 jobs · $8,446 in my last 9 months
Estimates a month, busy season and slow season
busy month
slow month
Busy and slow months are both used for the yearly numbers.
I signed about 15 to 19 jobs a month (595 in ~38 months)
Out of 10 estimates, how many sign?
% close
If he doesn't know, that's a finding. Note "doesn't track".
26.9% across 53,389 in-home home-improvement consults (Siro)
Bids from the last 12 months that never got a yes or a no
open bids
The quiet pile. This number sells the call.
My last 9 months: 54 bids, $434,211 sent back to sales
Booked estimates that cancelled or no-showed last month
last month
The before-the-estimate leak. No public benchmark, so log it.
Lead spend a month, and what a booked estimate costs you
$/mo now
$per estimate
Paying for leads? Then "are you signing the bids you paid for?"
How many times a bid gets followed up before someone stops
touches
Ask "on what days?" A vague answer means there's no system.
Most estimators quit after 3. Replies can take up to 10
How fast a new estimate request gets answered
Replying within 30 min: 25% more likely to be hired than at 3 hrs (Thumbtack 2025)
Crews in the field. Room for 20 to 30% more work this spring?
crews
No capacity means more signed work can't be delivered.
Where bids are tracked
Tells you how hard the old-bid export will be.
Ads: what you'd put into Meta a month, and a fair cost per booked estimate
$/mo ads
$per estimate
$125 is our assumption until 30 days of real data.
Start at $1,000 to $1,500/mo · $125 per booked estimate assumed
Step 3 · 8 minutes

Where your jobs leak

Walk one month of bids from booked to signed on screen. Let him say where it breaks.

One busy month of estimates, start to finish.

A busy month at your shop

Every estimate you book, and where it ends up.

Leak 1 · Before the estimate

Booked Tuesday. Nothing until the driveway.

Estimate booked for Tuesday, 4:00
No confirmation text
No reminder the day before
No intro video, so they've never seen your face
Tuesday, 2:41 PM
Hey, something came up today. We'll reach out to reschedule.
They don't.
Leak 2 · After the price

They got the number and went quiet.

Thursday
We'll think it over and get back to you.
Here's your exterior estimate. Happy to answer any questions!
Delivered
Monday
Just checking in on your estimate.
Read 9 days ago
No bid walkthrough video
No answers to prep, paint and schedule questions

Leak 3 · The follow-up stops too early

Before the estimate: does the homeowner hear from you between booking and the visit? Do they see your face first?
My pain point: last-minute cancels and no-shows with nothing confirming the visit
After the bid: walk me through day 1, day 3, day 10 and day 30 on a bid that went quiet.
My hardest part: getting homeowners to answer after they had the price
When a homeowner says "we'll think it over", what happens next?
Then ask"Which of these three looks most like your shop?"
Step 4 · 4 minutes

What it costs you

Ask first, before you scroll"If nothing changes, what does spring look like? What does it cost you to carry another season of quiet bids?"
His answer (his words)
$0
Sitting in open bids right now
$0
One kept estimate is worth (close rate × average job)
0
Bids that go quiet in a year
$0
Paid for estimates that went quiet, a year
Then ask"Does that number feel right, or am I off?" Then stop talking.
His reaction to the number
Step 5 · 6 minutes

The fix

Show only what fixes the leak he named. Flip to Follow-up + Ads if he wants more estimates too. Then drop the price.

Say"Here's what I'd install. It's the follow-up sequence I actually ran, set up in your shop."
01 · Fixes leak 1

Before the estimate

Confirmation, reminders and a short intro video, so homeowners show up.

02 · Fixes leak 2

After the bid

A bid walkthrough video that answers prep, paint and schedule questions before they ask.

03 · Fixes leak 3

Follow-up until there's an answer

A set schedule of texts, calls and emails until yes, no or "close my file".

04 · The quiet pile

One push on old bids

Every unsigned bid from the last 12 months, worked once. Plus a 60-second reply to new requests and my estimator scripts.

05 · Ads

New booked estimates

Meta ads into a qualifying page, booked straight onto your estimate calendar, and every one runs through the same follow-up.

What it costs you vs. what it costs to fix
Left on the table each year
$0
vs
The investment
$0
0
signed jobs pay for the build
0
job a month covers the monthly
0×
year-one return on the investment (estimate)

Guarantee (recommended, confirm before you say it)
Objections
"That's a lot."

"I already follow up."

"How many times, on what days? Most estimators stop after two or three tries, even when the homeowner was interested. I did too until I built a schedule. If you're already doing 7+ touches with video, you don't need me, and I'll tell you that."

"I get all my work from referrals."

"Great. That means your close rate is probably strong. The question is the referral bids that went quiet. How many from this year never answered? Let's count them."

"Winter's slow, call me in spring."

"Winter is the best time to install this. You have time to record two videos. Spring bids get chased automatically while you're on ladders. In April you'll be too busy to set it up."

"I got burned by an agency."

"What happened? (listen) That's why this isn't a long contract. You pay the build in two parts, and the second is due when it goes live."

"Homeowners hate being chased."

"Agreed. Nagging loses jobs. The messages answer what homeowners actually ask: prep, paint, schedule, what happens if it rains. It ends with a polite 'should I close your file?'"

"I just need more leads."

"Maybe. If you're signing [close]% and losing the rest to silence, more leads means more bids going quiet. Let's fix the follow-up first, or do both together." Then flip to Follow-up + Ads.

Step 6 · 2 minutes

Close or book the next step

Next step

Week 1

First payment holds a build slot

We pull your open bids and record your two videos.

Day 30

Go live

Second payment is due when it's live. Every quiet bid starts getting followed up.

Ask"Want to start? The first payment holds a build slot, and we'd go live in about 30 days."
Outcome
If not closed, book a time on the calendar before you hang up.
Is he the one who decides? Could he start within 30 days?
If no, get the decider on the follow-up call.
Follow-up booked for
Then run the post-call sequence: recap and video same day, then day 1, 3, 5, 7, 10, 14.
Do what you sell: 7+ touches, not 3
Next steps / notes
Copied